About the Author

author photo

Preet Banerjee, B.Sc., FMA, DMS is a former stockbroker and financial advisor in Toronto. Information on this site is for entertainment purposes ONLY. Always seek individual professional advice before making any financial decisions.

See All Posts by This Author

Severing The Link Between Price And Weight Part IV

                                                         
feature photo

Last post on this topic (at least for a while). Click on the following links for Part I, Part II, and Part III.

The final thoughts I wanted to share with you about this refer to the assumptions under which market cap-weighting an index suffers a drag when linking portfolio weight to price. We have already shown that overpriced stocks will be overweighted and underpriced stocks will be underweighted. These mispricings happen in every sector, and in every size of stock (small-, mid- and large-caps). How do we know which are overpriced and which are underpriced? We never know. No one knows what “fair value” is for any stock. But because the market has so many participants we assume that prices tend to revert towards fair-value more often than not. This does not preclude the market from getting prices drastically wrong at times, but with so many participants these mispricings are eventually identified and this is acted upon by the market and the result is the reversion to fairer prices.

So let me throw this out there to you: If the market is efficient enough that you can’t reliably outperform it, then is it fair to say that the market will tend to revert to fair prices on average? If it is fair to say that, then is accepting the drag of the price-weight link a necessary evil?

Popularity: 1% [?]

Credit Repair - option trading

<--Please click on the green Retweet button if you like this article and want to share it on Twitter!


You might like these Related Articles:
Severing The Link Between Price And Weight Part III
Severing The Link Between Price and Weight Part II
Severing The Link Between Price and Weight Part I
Fair Value Weighting Part II
Cap-Weighting Magnifies Your Exposure to Pricing Errors In The Wrong Ways
Join over 1,500 readers who receive daily updates by supplying your e-mail address:
 

You may also subscribe to the WhereDoesAllMyMoneyGo.com RSS feed:

There Are 2 Responses So Far. »

  1. That’s an easy question, as phrased: the answer is yes, it’s a necessary evil. If you can’t outperform the market, then anything you do to try to correct these “mispricings” can’t, by definition, help you outperform the market!

  2. [...] Preet wraps up his expose with Severing the Link Between Price and Weight Part IV. [...]

Post a Response